A search on dictionary.com for “trumping up” leads to the definition: to devise deceitfully or dishonestly, as an accusation; fabricate. Now try a Google search for “to trump someone.” yourdictionary.com leads you to: get the better of someone through a hidden source. Vocabulary.com says, “is to outrank or defeat someone, or something, often in a highly public way.”
I give you these 3 definitions as a prelude to my story. Before I give you the story however, I would like you to think about, why would you “trump up” someone or something? This is a true story, of a good friend of mine, but to respect him and give some kind of anonymity I will call him Mr. South. He’s from the south, but moved to New York partly to get away from the life he was heading toward.
South is about 26. He moved to New York a few years ago. He was working nights full time at a well known store in Manhattan. He was well liked, went to school, and lived on his own in room he rented. His managers liked him, he never caused or got into any trouble. In fact, he was promoted during the time he worked there. In school, he did well. He liked architecture and went to City College of New York not far from his home. He was receiving financial aid in order to afford school. He liked it. He felt good about it – about himself. He’d left “that life” behind. He still went back home from time to time; he has family there, friends.
I genuinely like South. He’s a good guy. His past does not make him, but rather shaped the man he was becoming – the man he wanted to be. The man he will be. The past is always with you, a part of you, and helped you either positively or negatively become who you stand to be in your future. For South, it was proving positive. Back home he had gotten into trouble when he was younger, gun charge, two gun charges, and a [short] time in jail for it. That’s why he wanted something different. That’s why he moved. He’d seen people close to him fall to a fate he did not want for himself – death and prison.
His future is on pause.
South is currently in Manhattan’s Detention Center (MDC). What happened right? I just finished telling you he was a good guy telling you that he was someone who was on the road to positive things, better things than the MDC. South is currently being held on a 20K cash bond – not that 10% bail bondsman kind of deal. It will cost $20,000 for him to see and breathe day light – aside from the rooftop of the MDC.
I couldn’t believe it. Why was South there? I conjured up all these ideas in my head. None of them seemed believable. I knew him. I thought at least. It just didn’t make sense, it didn’t add up. South’s most serious charge is 1st degree felony robbery. Did you check what that means? Queensdefense.com says, “robbery in the First Degree is a class B violent felony in New York. This is the most serious form of robbery and it carries a 25 year maximum prison term upon conviction and a five year mandatory minimum for someone with no criminal record.” South has a previous record, a gun charge. He didn’t hurt someone with the gun. He had it on his person and was caught with it. It was not licensed to him. The fact that he did not hurt someone does not make having a gun illegally okay. I do not condone the use of guns for any means, except hunting [animals], but I digress. South could face 25 years if convicted of this charge. What the deck did he do!
I went to see him – myself and a friend he also knows. The experience was a bit surreal. We went with no belongings except for our ID, money, and a Metro Card. We walked through a metal detector upon entering the front. We dropped our money, ID, and Metro Card in a bin similar to those at the airport. We were still search. We turned our pockets inside out and showed we had nothing. I guess somehow the lack of belongings seemed strange. We got to bypass the next line. We didn’t have any bags. We gave our names, our ID, or finger prints, and the arrest # of the person we were going to see. He’s a number now, even though his name is listed alongside those numbers when they pull him up in the system. If you’re going to treat people like cattle, you’ve got to dehumanize them first – tagged and numbered just like cattle. We went through another door. Walked through a metal detector, dropped our things in another bin, took off all our jewelry, our piercings, everything, and were told to wear this huge (and hideous) lime green shirts. I love loud colors, but even these were too much to bare. We waited for our names to be called. We hadn’t told South we were coming. Would he accept the visit? I didn’t know, after all I couldn’t even believe we were there to see him. I looked around the room. It was black, brown, and that hideous green, not the walls, the people. I thought to myself, damn, not even one person closely resembling white. We were called. Went through this capsule like door with no shoes on. (What was on this floor?) and got extensively search. Our bras were checked, the soles of our feet, the insoles of our shoes, the bottoms of them, the lining of our underwear, pockets (again), damn near every inch of us was checked. We got in sat down – in two chairs they had to connect for us (because some how our chairs connecting make a difference) and finally South came down. He wore a jump suit and slippers. He said that was what he wore for “work”. He worked in the visiting area. We were his first and only visitors in the three months he had been there. I was glad I came. He had gained some weight. It looked good on him, though – I wish high caloric jail food wasn’t the source of it. We made a little small talk before I asked, “so what happened?!” “I knew that was coming” South said. Of course we were going to ask him. We didn’t go through the cattle treatment to NOT ask. He told us. South had loaned some guy some money. He dipped and dodged him for months. South counted it as an L (a loss) until he saw him months later. South approached him, beat him up, and took his phone. About 5 blocks later cops ran up on him as he was going to the train station – guns drawn like he just killed someone. Someone (or the guy) called the cops. South had the guys phone, so they knew it was him, and he was taken in. South didn’t use a weapon, He didn’t beat him up to a pulp. He didn’t die, break anything, go into a coma, nothing major. Most people would just say, the dude got was coming to him. If anything it was larceny since the phone was (technically) worth over $600.
WHAT?! Are you thinking what I was thinking? 1st Degree Felony Robbery for an iPhone and a little beat down the guy deserved. He owed his debt and South found his payment that day. That’s how it should’ve gone, but instead South is still in the MDC. He’s been there since July. South lost his job, his apartment, and his education. He sees it as a set back. He still plans to move on with his life positively after this, but if he’s charge with a felony – there goes his chance for federal financial aid. Felons aren’t award that kind of aid. You’re let out with the intention and good faith that you will be a positive contribution to society. How could you do that without a college education? We all know college is more than important when looking for a quality job.
He’s charged with a few lesser things, but they’ve trumped up the charges on him. Largely the reasoning behind trumping the charges is to implicate someone as well as painting a deceitful picture of the individual. The city is getting approximately $300 from him for every day he’s in there. That’s without the virtually free work they get from him in the visiting center. He gets paid a few cents an hour and people say slavery doesn’t exist. The slavery and the money the city is getting has to be justifiable. You can’t just make that kind of money off of someone without justification. And so, South is charged with 1st degree felony robbery for the theft of an iPhone and a minor beat down the guy had coming to him anyway. It was his poor decision that lead him to the arrest. Yes, that I believe as does he. But being in the Manhattan Detention Center since mid-July, losing your job, your apartment, and a chance at losing your education for an iPhone – well you just couldn’t trump that story unless of course they’ve trumped your charges too.
notjustmythoughts
Dedicated to South and the many others (largely black and brown) that are cattled thru the system daily on trumped charges.